[ §1 · timing ]

DRSSTC ZCS vs ZVS, and whether a snubber helps or costs

DRSSTC

Switching off exactly at the current zero sounds ideal but is not. A little residual current is needed to swing the bridge node, and switching late kills parts while switching early only adds heat.

Turning off exactly at the current zero looks like the ideal, but it leaves no current to recharge the leg during the dead time, the short gap in which neither device in the leg is on:

switch off exactly at zero current  ->  no current left
                                    ->  nothing to recharge the leg's capacitance
                                        during the dead time
                                    ->  the opposite device turns on into the
                                        full bus, hard

The residual current at turn-off is what commutates the node, that is, swings it from one rail to the other. Zero current switching (ZCS) and zero voltage switching (ZVS) trade against each other, and you cannot have both. This article covers why the margin belongs on the early side of the current zero, how much lead a bridge needs to recharge its node within the dead time, and whether a snubber capacitor across the switch helps.

Choosing between clean ZCS and ZVS

Both quotes below are from HVF 1788, where V-Troxi could not get his UD2.7-driven QCW to switch cleanly and davekni answered him.

V-Troxi: I prefer to have ZVS because I'm building a QCW with long on times. davekni: I'd keep clean ZCS (ZVS for IGBT turn-on), even though IGBT switch-off losses are higher at higher current. You can reduce turn-off current, that is reduce phase lead, if you first reduce dead time.

These are two views of the same coil, and the part in brackets is the bit people skip. davekni is not arguing for hard turn-on anywhere. He wants the turn-off clean at the current zero and the turn-on still at zero volts, and he gets there with a shorter dead time rather than more lead, meaning switching further ahead of the current zero. That is a different remedy from V-Troxi's, on the same bridge, and which one suits depends on how much dead time you are carrying.

Why switching late is worse than switching early

LATE   ->  the diode conducts  ->  reverse recovery
       ->  hard turn-on of the opposite device  ->  overshoot  ->  death

EARLY  ->  turn-off at non-zero current  ->  slightly more loss
device voltagegatemargin
Watch the order, not the shapes. The voltage has to reach the bottom before the gate starts up. The shaded gap between them is the margin, and the lead is there to create it.

Induction heating reaches the same asymmetry from the other end and states it as a tuning rule. A DRSSTC is a series resonant inverter, which is also what high frequency induction heating runs on, and that field has had decades to work out where to sit relative to resonance. A survey reposted on hvdiy by 混世魔王x86 opens by saying so, "DRSSTC实际是个串联谐振逆变器", a DRSSTC is in fact a series resonant inverter, and then works through both sides of resonance (hvdiy 35902).

Below resonance the load is capacitive, the current leads the voltage, and commutation hands off from the diodes to the opposite arm's switches, which is the reverse recovery case above. Above resonance the load is inductive, the current lags, and turn-off happens before the current zero. There is some turn-off loss, but the turn-off time is short and so is the dead time needed. Their conclusion could go straight onto a coil driver: "适当地控制逆变器的工作频率并使之略高于负载电路的谐振频率", control the inverter's operating frequency appropriately and keep it slightly above the load circuit's resonant frequency.

That is early rather than late, reached independently by people whose machines run continuously and cannot afford the diode. The rule is not just a Tesla coil convention.

Late kills the devices, early only heats them. Keep the margin on the early side, always.

Photograph of an analogue oscilloscope screen showing two green traces built of short repeated segments, one across the upper half and one across the lower half. Each segment is a sloping line with a thin vertical spike at its start; the last segment on each trace is wider and curved. A white label in the bottom left corner reads: Output from a half-bridge: Rg(on/off) = 20/0 ohms, Vg(on/off) = 30V/-8V. T-delay = ~850nS after current zero crossing. Rail voltage excursion: 15% max. Vce spike = 30% max. Note: normal Vce excursion is 5 divisions, Vce spike is ~1 div above max.
The late side as one builder met it: Ward's half bridge on DRSSTC-2, his note giving a delay of about 850 ns after the current zero and a Vce spike of up to 30 per cent, which his page puts down to diode recovery and tamed by slowing turn-on with a 20 ohm gate resistor. Scope capture by Steve Ward, from his DRSSTC-2 page, used with his permission.

The loss from switching late is Q_rr × V, where Q_rr is the diode's recovered charge. It is strictly proportional to that charge, so treat Q_rr as a variable rather than a fixed fact. At 1 µC, a figure for this device class and not a measurement of ours, that is 440 µJ per device at 440 V, 1.76 mJ per leg per transition, and kilowatts at the top of the ramp. A part with half the recovered charge halves every one of those numbers. Read your own Q_rr off your own datasheet and scale the column directly.

How much residual current is enough

The criterion is that the node has to recharge within the dead time, not within the whole lead interval. The charge available in the first t_dead of that interval is:

Q(t_dead) = I_pk/(2·pi·f) · [cos(2·pi·f(dt - t_dead)) - cos(2·pi·f·dt)]
            >= C_node · V_bus

Solve for the smallest dt and you have the floor.

A worked case: four IPW65R080CFD per leg at C_o(tr) = 794 pF, 440 V, 37 ns of dead time, 170 A peak, 490 kHz. One device holds C_o · V = 349 nC, so a leg of four holds 1.397 µC. The factor of four against a single-device figure is a bigger bridge, not a different number.

  • no external snubber, 3.18 nF per leg: 91 ns of lead needed for ZVS;
  • 100 pF added, 3.58 nF: 101 ns;
  • 235 pF, 4.12 nF: 113 ns;
  • 470 pF, 5.06 nF: 136 ns.

Every snubber capacitor you add to soften the edges is lead you have to find somewhere else.

There is no independent check on these rows. Four rows were solved by hand some time ago, reading 80, 90, 105 and 125 ns. On an input of 675 pF the equation returns 80.3, 89.5, 102.2 and 124.5 [derived]. That made them look like agreement. But 675 pF is on neither Infineon sheet for this part. The data sheet gives 794 typical, and on that the same equation returns 91.3, 100.7, 113.4 and 136.0 [derived], nowhere near the hand sheet. The hand sheet was therefore solved on the same wrong capacitance, and two calculations sharing an input agree with each other whatever the input is. The rows above use the manufacturer's figure and have no outside check at all.

How the required lead changes along a QCW ramp

The lead required grows towards the end of a ramp, because the frequency is lower and the same charge has to be moved within a larger fraction of a period. The L+R network that makes the lead, an inductor working against the current transformer's burden resistor, also delivers more time at the lower frequency.

The frequencies below are this machine's upper pole, 519.1 kHz falling to 463.3 on a 1.5 m arc, which is the trajectory used everywhere on this site. At 18.1 µH, with the delay chain cold:

  • 519.1 kHz: 77 ns needed, 73 given. Minus 4.
  • 490 kHz: 80 needed, 79 given. Minus 1.
  • 476 kHz: 82 needed, 83 given. Plus 1.
  • 463.3 kHz: 84 needed, 85 given. Plus 2.

The given column is the network's total lead less the delay chain: 263 ns at the top of the ramp less the 190 ns the chain eats, and 275 less 190 at the bottom. The chain is the propagation delays from the comparator through to the switch, added up. The 190 is not a free choice here. The inductor was worked out from it, as L = R·tan(2πf·(T_d + T_ZVS))/2πf at 490 kHz, so the inductor and the chain are one decision, not two.

The figure stays at 18.1 rather than moving to 19.5, because 18.1 is a slug somebody would set and we have never measured this bridge, so we are not going to redesign it. The equation just does not return it. It went unnoticed for so long because not one input to the equation is a measurement. T_d has never been measured on this machine, the floor is a calculation from C_o(tr), and the 51 Ω is the burden on Ward's UD2.1 revB schematic rather than anything read off a meter. Three unmeasured inputs will agree with an answer chosen in advance, and these did.

The frequency article works the same network across the same trajectory and gets 258 and 270 where the figures here are 263 and 275. The two do not conflict. It anchors L/R at 45 degrees at the bottom of the ramp, which is 344 ns. Here L/R comes from the reference build's own inductor, 355 ns, so every row sits about 5 ns higher. Its fall across the ramp is 11.7 ns against the 12.2 here, and neither figure is a measurement. Read the two tables as one geometry at two anchors, and take the anchor from whichever question you are asking.

What the network sets is L/R, here 355 ns, and the burden splits that between henries and ohms: 18.1 µH against the 51 Ω a stock board carries, or 1.28 µH against 3.6. Which one to build is decided at the current transformer rather than here, and the small burden wins, because a large one feeds the lower pole more lead than the upper.

The 218 needs explaining, because the obvious route gives a different answer and the gap is bigger than the column. Warm means the switch's t_d(off) runs about 30 per cent longer, which the phase lead page works out as 34.5 ns on its 115 ns switch. Add that to the cold midpoint of the chain, 184 ns, and you get 218.5, the model's expected case and the figure used above. Add it to the 190 subtracted everywhere else here and you get 224.5, and the four rows read -38, -35, -34, -33 [derived] instead. The two routes differ by 6.5 ns, more than the 5.2 ns the cold column spans, and only because 184 and 190 are two summaries of one chain. Nothing here picks between them, so read the warm rows as the milder of the two warm cases.

Cold, the shortfall is at the start of the ramp rather than spread over it. 18.1 µH was solved at 490 kHz, the middle of this trajectory and not its top, so the first stretch runs about 4 ns inside the floor. That is the stretch with no arc on the coil, where the secondary Q is at its highest and the bridge is least forgiving. Solve for the inductor at the top of the pole trajectory, not at a frequency taken from the middle of it.

Whatever its sign, the margin does grow across the ramp. That result holds through all the uncertainty above, because it is a difference between rows. The floor rises more slowly than one over frequency, 9 per cent from 519.1 down to 463.3 kHz against 12 for 1/f. The network's delivered time is very nearly linear in frequency across this span, its slope holding to within 3 per cent [derived, 0.2173, 0.2209 and 0.2230 ns per kHz across the three intervals between the four rows, a spread of 2.6]. That is what "the arctangent is still nearly linear here" means. It is the one place in a QCW where something does not get harder as the arc grows.

Read the column as a shape, and as the cold bridge. T_d has never been measured on this machine. The 190 is a datasheet sum whose links are ranges, giving 167 to 202, and a bench figure anywhere from 140 to 260 would be accepted. The 80 ns floor is a calculation too. The chain enters every row as one subtraction, so it moves all four margins together. At 167 the column reads plus 19 to plus 25, at 202 it reads minus 16 to minus 10, and the warm case above sits below all of that. The column itself spans 5.2 ns. Every one of those bands is wider than that, most by a great deal, and the model behind it carries three cases where the column prints one. The differences between the rows never touch the chain, and those are what the previous paragraph is about. The absolute figures are not margin anyone can spend. Where the chain comes from, link by link, is on the phase lead page.

Whether to add a snubber capacitor across the switch

Two different parts are called a snubber, and they are a thousand times apart. Everything in this section is the one across the switch, measured in picofarads, which adds to the node capacitance and so needs more phase lead. The other sits across the module's DC terminals, is measured in microfarads, and does not touch the lead at all. Both appear on the site: 100, 235 and 470 pF here, against a 0.22 µF part on the margin page, 2 µF across a module on the device page, and 8.8 µF counted into a bus on the buck page. Each of those pages is right, as long as you do not read them as one component.

The bus snubber exists because energy is trapped in the busbar's stray inductance when a large current stops. It is sized on that energy rather than on the lead: it has to swallow L_s·I²/2 while its own voltage rises by no more than the device can stand above the bus. Every term in that is set by the layout and the current, so it belongs with the margin page.

A snubber capacitor across a leg is a bet, not insurance, and the payoff depends entirely on whether you get zero voltage switching.

  • ZVS achieved: the snubber's energy returns to the tank, and nothing is lost.
  • ZVS missed: CV²/2 goes into the die on every transition.

For four 470 pF per leg at 440 V that is 182 µJ per transition, which comes to 50 W at 14 per cent duty across both legs of a full bridge at 490 kHz [derived, C·V²/2 on 1.88 nF and 440 V, then two transitions a cycle, two legs, 490 kHz and 0.14]. The snubber doubles the penalty for failing.

The device's own output capacitance already acts as a snubber

Before adding any, look at what is already there:

C_o(tr) = 794 pF per device   (IPW65R080CFD, typical)
t_f = 6 ns
I at turn-off = 41.6 A        (this bridge's own residual, from the phase lead page)
dV during the current fall = I·t/C = 41.6 A × 6 ns / 3.176 nF = 78.6 V

The current has already fallen while the voltage is still low. External capacitance adds little to that.

The capacitance on that line is Infineon's. Their IPW65R080CFD data sheet, Rev. 2.4, Table 5, gives 794 pF typical, for a capacitance defined there as the one "that gives the same charging time as Coss while V_DS is rising from 0 to 400V"; the IPW65R080CFDA sheet, Rev. 2.1, gives 754. The 675 pF used here before is on neither the sheet for this part nor the sheet for its automotive twin, and no revision carrying it could be found. Four other device figures here match that sheet word for word, and they are listed at the end. The floor calculation above and the phase lead page both run on 794 pF.

The current on that line is this bridge's own. Earlier versions used 35 A, a figure with no source and no derivation behind it; the only other 35 A on the site belongs to Uspring's LTspice model of Jan's coil, a different machine whose measured peak is 100 A. The same bridge's residual on the phase lead page is 41.6 A, and it comes back a second way from that page's published figures: 170 A peak into sin(2π·490 kHz·80.3 ns) is 41.60 A [derived]. The capacitance correction does not change it, because the lead this coil's network delivers is 79 ns whatever the floor is, and 170 A into sin(2π·490 kHz·79 ns) is 40.9 A [derived]. What moves with the capacitance is the floor and the residual at the floor, not the residual on the bench.

Superjunction output capacitance is non-linear

C_oss   = 215 pF   (V_GS = 0 V, V_DS = 100 V, f = 1 MHz)
C_o(er) = 158 pF   (energy related, across a 0 to 400 V transition)
C_o(tr) = 794 pF   (time related, across a 0 to 400 V transition)

The last is 3.7 times the first. In the middle of the swing the capacitance is at its minimum while current is still flowing:

dV/dt_peak = I / (N · C_oss_min)

Worked: 41.6 A / (4 × 215 pF) = 48 V/ns [derived]. On the time related capacitance the same current gives 13.1 V/ns [derived, 41.6 A / 3.176 nF]. The factor of 3.7 between the two matters, because the rate the device sees mid-transition is the one on the smaller capacitance.

Table 2 of the same data sheet gives MOSFET dv/dt ruggedness as a maximum of 50 V/ns at V_DS = 0 to 400 V, and it does not say which rate it means. Read as a bound on the instantaneous rate, 48 is 97 per cent of it [derived] and there is nothing left to spend. Read as a bound on the average rate across the whole swing, this bridge is at 13.1 V/ns, 26 per cent [derived], and the question does not arise. The sheet does not distinguish the two readings. Size on the first.

An 81 per cent figure that used to appear here was the same sum on the old 35 A [derived, 35 A / 860 pF is 40.7 V/ns, which is 81 per cent of 50]. Do not confuse the 50 V/ns with the other 50 V/ns on this site, the common-mode transient immunity asked of anything crossing the isolation boundary in what RF ground is. That one is a driver's rating, not a die's, and the two are unrelated.

Weston describes the same effect when he says superjunction FETs are poor in high frequency resonance: a non-linear lossy Coss gives voltage spikes and lower efficiency even under ZVS.

The two limits on snubber capacitance

The dead time says the capacitance must be small, because the charge has to be moved within it. dV/dt ruggedness says it must not be too small. The optimum is where they meet.

On this bridge they meet at zero external capacitance. A figure of 100 to 150 pF was given here before, with no inputs behind it and nothing arriving at it, and it does not hold. Both walls can now be placed.

The lower one comes straight off the ruggedness line: 41.6 A / 50 V/ns is 832 pF a leg, 208 pF a device [derived]. The four devices bring 860 pF of their own, which clears it by 3 per cent [derived] before anything is added. Three per cent is not margin, but it is the right side of the wall.

The upper wall is already closed. The floor calculation gives 91 ns of lead for ZVS with no external snubber at all, 101 ns at 100 pF a device and 136 ns at 470, while the network on this coil delivers 79 ns at 490 kHz. The dead time wall therefore stands at zero external capacitance here, and every picofarad added is lead that has to be found somewhere else. Four hundred and seventy is past it by a long way. To one decimal, on the datasheet's 794 pF, those three rows are 91.3, 100.7 and 136.0 ns, so the bare bridge is already short of its own floor, as flagged at the top.

Ways to close the lead shortfall

Every term in the gap is a number now, so the gap can be costed.

First, where the 79 comes from. The network's angle is arctan(wL/R), and 18.1 µH against 51 Ω at 490 kHz is 47.54°, which on a 2041 ns period is 269.5 ns of lead. The delay chain takes 190 of it. What is left in front of the current zero is 79.5 ns [derived, all three].

That is the cold bridge. On the warm chain of 218 ns the same network leaves 51.5 ns against the same 91.3 floor, so the shortfall goes from 11.8 ns to 39.8 [derived]. The warm case is the one that binds, as it is for everything else on this machine.

what closes it                       floor      what it costs
three devices a leg, not four        72.9 ns    a quarter of the bridge
bus down to 366 V                    78.9       17 per cent of the voltage
L to 19.5 µH, angle 47.5 -> 49.6     91.3       covers the cold case only
L to 23.3 µH, angle 47.5 -> 54.6     91.3       covers the warm case
a part with less C_o(tr)             38.1       the Warp2's 215 pF, at four

[derived, every row]. The inductance route is the one that stays available. davekni's practical ceiling on an L+R lead is 60°, which on this burden is 28.7 µH and 340 ns of total lead, so even the warm fix at 54.6° is inside it with room left. It is not free, though, because the burden and the coil move together and the ratio is what the network sets.

A published sizing rule lands on the other side of that, and which of the two capacitances above you feed it moves its answer by the same 3.7 times. T3sl4co1l writes it as C >= 2.5·Coss with R = sqrt(L_stray/Coss). Fed the 215 pF reading that is a floor of 538 pF per device, fed the 794 pF one it is 1985 [derived], and the rule itself does not say which reading to use. Either way it puts the 470 pF row above on the wrong side, and in the opposite direction to the dead time: too little rather than too much. The two criteria point away from each other with nothing in between.

The rule was also written for a different class of device. In the same post he gives his own working value for the machine in front of him, "C around 4.7 or 10nF seems good enough", because, in the sentence before it, "Coss is a few nF for most IGBTs of useful size; it will decrease at higher voltages". Fed a superjunction MOSFET's picofarads, the same rule returns picofarads, an order of magnitude below the answer he gave in the thread.

These are two different jobs rather than a contradiction. His rule is for damping a layout's ringing, and the machine in that thread has 116 nH of loop inductance ringing at 3.3 MHz, which he tells the builder to fix by redoing the board rather than by sizing around it. Here the job is sizing a transition that is meant to be lossless in the first place. No published source puts the two against one device, so applying his rule to this example is our step, and nothing yet closes the gap between them.

An external antiparallel diode never conducts

body diode of the MOSFET, V_SD = 0.9 V   (typical at I_F = 26.3 A, V_GS = 0 V)
external SiC Schottky, Vf     = 1.5 to 1.8 V

The external one will never turn on. You can check this in a minute by measuring both on a meter's diode range.

On a CFD, a Cool Fast Diode part, Q_rr is 1 µC typical, stated at V_R = 400 V, I_F = 26.3 A and 100 A/µs, against 10 or more for an ordinary superjunction. Its body diode therefore recovers fast enough that nothing external is needed. Where you might want something is the opposite part, one whose body diode is slow, and even there a parallel diode does not help. With a higher forward drop it cannot take the current away from the body diode, so the recovery happens anyway. The fix there is a different device.


This covers the floor half of the phase lead. The other half is the delay chain, and both are in what a phase lead actually buys. Figures here are calculated from published device data, not measured by us.

The device figures are Infineon's and are linked where they appear. C_oss, t_f at its stated 400 V and 26.3 A, V_SD and Q_rr match Table 5 and Table 7 of the IPW65R080CFD data sheet word for word, as do C_o(tr), C_o(er) and the dv/dt ruggedness line the snubber sizing relies on. The arithmetic on them is ours. The old 675 pF figure for C_o(tr) has been replaced on every page that used it.

more in DRSSTC →