An SSTC has no primary resonant capacitor, so its primary switches at maximum current. That is davekni's short answer, and he adds that zero current switching is a DRSSTC thing (HVF 1355).
He later edited that post to point four replies down the same thread, at Uspring, who says soft switching on an SSTC is possible and gives the condition for it. davekni's answer is the right default, and his own edit says there is more to it.
Soft switching means the bridge switches near the zero of its current instead of at the peak. This article covers what that would give, how much coupling and loaded Q it needs, and what the arc does to it. After it you can work out k²Q for your own coil and see which side of the condition it is on.
What soft switching would give
Richie Burnett lists the benefits on his driver theory pages, with one precondition on all of them: the current passes through zero at the switching instant only when the driver is perfectly in tune with the resonator. Given that,
- switching losses are greatly reduced, because no current flows at the switching instant and the heating left is conduction;
- spikes and ringing are greatly reduced, because
di/dtis the slope of a sinusoid rather than many amps interrupted in tens of nanoseconds; - paralleled switches share better, because the current is near zero for some time around each switching instant, so a mismatch in switching times matters less.
Losing the third is hard to spot. A paralleled assembly that loses soft switching suffers twice, first in loss and then in sharing, and only the second shows, as one device running hot. IGBT or MOSFET has the sharing rule.
The condition for soft switching
Uspring, in the same thread, answering davekni's question of whether an 80 cm arc leaves the secondary any Q to work with:
Q needs to be about 1/k^2 or more.
Q is the secondary's loaded quality factor and k is the coupling. His next sentence gives the mechanism, which is more useful than the inequality. The secondary current has to be large enough to cancel the primary inductance. That takes a high Q to produce the current and a high coupling for the primary to feel it.
Burnett's reflected model gives the same result as an angle. He shows the secondary's series resonance appearing across the primary winding as a transformed load, so the bridge current has two components. The magnetising current is triangular, ninety degrees behind the voltage, and flows whether or not anything is coupled to the winding. The resonant current is in phase and does the work. His reflected resistance at resonance is Rs' = Rs·Lp/(k²·Ls), and he gives the magnetising current as inversely proportional to both the frequency and Lp, which is V/(2·pi·f·Lp). So
I_resonant / I_magnetising = k² · Q [derived, from those two expressions]
phi = arctan( 1 / (k² · Q) )
This is Uspring's condition written as a phase instead of a threshold. The exact two-port model of a coupled pair gets there by a different route and agrees. At the secondary's resonance the bridge sees 2·pi·f·Lp·k²·Q in series with 2·pi·f·Lp, and their ratio is the same k²Q [derived]. Two models giving one expression is the cross-check we want before a figure gets used elsewhere.
At the boundary the lag is not zero. k²Q = 1 is a lag of 45 degrees [derived, arctan 1]. Meeting the condition does not mean switching at the current zero, only that the current is more in phase than in quadrature.
Lenz has a different condition written on the same two symbols. Qsec < 1/k is where the pair of poles collapses, and it is covered in there is no secondary frequency. That one asks whether the resonances hold up under the load; Uspring's asks whether the bridge current is in phase with the bridge voltage. At k = 0.5 they sit at Q = 2 and Q = 4 [derived, 1/k and 1/k²], so a coil above 4 is on the safe side of both, and nothing here contradicts that article.
How much coupling the condition needs
1/k² climbs fast as the coupling drops, and that is the main argument for winding an SSTC primary tight.
k Q the condition demands
0.15 44.4 a DRSSTC's coupling
0.35 8.2 Burnett's floor for an SSTC primary
0.40 6.3 his project coil
0.55 3.3 his design page coil
These couplings are real published figures, not illustrations. The 0.15 and Burnett's three figures, with his own hedges on the last two, are on an SSTC primary is a different part.
For the Q, we have only one secondary with a published loaded figure, and it is a QCW's, not an SSTC's: unloaded Q 199, and 7.59 under a metre and a half of arc, on the secondary is a resonator. Here is that one coil at three couplings:
k no arc 1.5 m of arc
k²Q lag k²Q lag
0.15 4.48 12.6° 0.171 80.3°
0.35 24.4 2.3° 0.930 47.1°
0.55 60.2 1.0° 2.30 23.5°
[derived throughout, arctan(1/k²Q) on that page's 199 and 7.59]
Every entry in the no-arc column clears the condition. With the arc, it depends on the coupling. This is one coil with the primary moved, which is the thing a builder can change, not three different machines. Down the left, even a DRSSTC's loose primary switches nearly softly before breakout. Across the top row, the arc takes the same coil to 80 degrees, which is switching at the current peak. At 0.55 it still holds 23 degrees under the arc.
Break-even is k = 0.363 [derived, the square root of 1 over 7.59], and Burnett's stated floor for the method is above 0.35. One is a builder's empirical floor for power transfer and the other a phase condition from a different model. They land within four per cent of each other, and neither man was arguing for the other's number.
They are still different claims. Burnett's reason for tight coupling is transformer action, and he is explicit about it: spark breakout "loads the secondary winding ruining the Q", so resonant rise is no good afterwards and the coupling has to carry the step-up instead. Uspring's condition is a second consequence of the same tightening, not a replacement for the first. What links them is the arc. Its arrival is what makes tight coupling necessary and soft switching hard.
Checking the coil in the thread against the condition
Rapy2's machine is the one davekni and Uspring were discussing, and it is the only SSTC here with enough published to check. It has a 40 cm secondary of 0.35 mm wire on a 110 mm form running about 240 kHz, a primary of 10 turns at 125 mm, a bus to 390 V, 80 cm sparks, and a full bridge of FGA60N65SMD. He posts the secondary's inductance as 37.6, in microhenries.
The unit is a slip. Correct it rather than drop it, because Uspring's advice is written in terms of impedance. Wheeler on the geometry Rapy2 states returns 28 to 35 mH [derived, 110 mm on 400 mm close wound, the spread being whether the 0.35 mm is measured over the varnish or under it], so it is millihenries. The spread is also a reminder that the turn count depends on more than the wire's bare diameter. Take 37.6 mH at his own 240 kHz and the resonating capacitance is 11.7 pF, so √(L/C) is 57 kΩ [derived].
Uspring says that is too high. In the post carrying the condition he adds that for an 80 cm arc the secondary impedance should be below the typical 50k, "maybe 15 or 20k", because under an arc the loaded Q is the arc's resistance over that impedance and very little else. Rapy2's coil sits above the typical figure, not below it.
Here is what that does to his loaded Q. We use 210 kΩ for a metre and a half of arc, from Hydron's measurements of his own toroid currents (HVF 117), scaled as one over length, which gives 394 kΩ at Rapy2's 80 cm [derived]. 394 over 57 is a loaded Q near 6.9 from the arc alone, or 6.7 with the winding's own 199 alongside [derived]. The condition then needs k above 0.38, which is Burnett territory. At Uspring's 15 to 20 kΩ the same arc gives 20 to 26, and the demand falls to k above 0.20 to 0.23 [derived]. Rapy2's coupling is not published, so the check stops there. We can say what his impedance demands, not whether his primary supplies it.
The obvious objection is that the 210 kΩ and its scaling come from a different machine, and they do. No SSTC here has a measured arc resistance. The borrowing errs on the safe side: a shorter arc has a higher resistance and so a higher loaded Q, which makes these figures kind to the SSTC rather than harsh. They cannot be a specification for a particular coil.
How well established this is
Not well, and Uspring says so himself in the same post. He had never seen a working ZCS (zero current switching) SSTC, and his was speculation on theoretical grounds. The cancellation of the primary inductance is usually very incomplete, because either the Q or the coupling is not large enough. Near the secondary's resonance a real coil usually shows a dip in the primary impedance rather than a null.
davekni's own reaction, once Rapy2 posted the design he had copied, was that it looks to have high coupling and that ZCS with large arcs was still surprising to him.
The nearest published capture is older than the thread, and it shows a different thing:

The thread names one builder as having done it, and we have not seen the evidence. Rapy2 credits a Slovak SSTC-5 page at vn-experimenty.eu as where he got the idea. That address returned Access Forbidden when we tried it on 20 August 2026, so nothing from it is used here and it is not linked. What can be cited is that the page was posted in the thread and that davekni read its coupling as high.
Soft switching takes time to build up in a burst
Uspring's second caveat is in the same post. Even with the condition met, the secondary current has to build up, so soft switching does not appear at the start of a burst. He files the whole option under CW (continuous wave) or QCW rather than short bangs.
How long it takes follows from the same Q. A resonator's envelope rises with a time constant of 2Q over the angular frequency, which is Q/pi cycles [derived]. On the figures above that is 63 cycles with no arc, about two once a metre and a half of arc is loading it, and about four at 80 cm. The high Q that satisfies the condition also makes the coil slow to reach it.
How this relates to not switching exactly at zero
The numbers
- The condition:
Q > 1/k², Uspring's, on the secondary's loadedQ. - The lag it produces:
arctan(1/k²Q), withk²Q= 1 at 45 degrees [derived]. - What it demands in
Q: 44.4 atk= 0.15, 8.2 at 0.35, 6.3 at 0.40 and 3.3 at 0.55 [derived]. - The only published loaded secondary here: 199 unloaded and 7.59 under a 1.5 m arc, and it is a QCW's, not an SSTC's.
- Break-even coupling on it: 0.363 under that arc [derived], against Burnett's stated floor of above 0.35 for an SSTC primary.
- Secondary impedance Uspring asks for at an 80 cm arc: below the typical 50 kΩ, and he suggests 15 or 20.
- Switching loss when the condition fails: davekni works out Rapy2's bridge from the datasheet, 0.78 mJ of turn-off energy at 60 A, which at 240 kHz is 187 W of switching against about 40 W of conduction, 227 W per device. Switching is 4.7 times conduction [derived].
- His conclusion is not that the devices are wrong. He puts continuous operation within reach of those IGBTs given thermal compound and cooling for about 900 W across all four. He separately notes that most SSTC designs he has seen use FETs, with fast IGBTs working in spite of the high current switching, especially where the enable duty is low. The choice itself is IGBT or MOSFET, which gives the reason as an SSTC's modest current. The two readings agree. The current is modest next to a DRSSTC's tank, but it is at its maximum at the switching instant, and that is what switching loss depends on.
What goes wrong
- Setting the driver for ZCS and losing the bridge. This was Rapy2's failure, as Uspring read it. With the condition unmet, what sits near the secondary's resonance is a dip in primary impedance rather than a null, and the dip was deep enough to raise the current until the devices went. Moving the frequency towards resonance raises the current before it straightens the phase.
- Hard switching on a coil that calculated as soft. Check
k²Qon the arc'sQ, not the unloaded one. The condition holds comfortably before breakout and can fail after it, and on the coil above the swing is 12.6 degrees to 80.3. - A DRSSTC primary geometry reused on an SSTC. At
k= 0.15 the arc-loadedQwould have to stay above 44.4, and no loaded figure published here comes near that. - Paralleled devices that share badly only at high power. Same cause. Soft switching was carrying the sharing and the arc took it away.
- Devices that survive the bench and die on the arc. The bench had no load to ruin the
Q. It is the same trap as reading a hard-switched datasheet pulse as a rating, which IGBT or MOSFET covers. - Soft switching that appears late in the burst and not at the start. That is expected. The secondary current has to build first.
Where next
- An SSTC primary is a different part, the winding this condition asks for, and where Burnett's coupling figures and his magnetising current live.
- The secondary is a resonator, where the loaded
Qcomes from. - There is no secondary frequency, for Lenz's
Qsec < 1/k, a different condition on the same two symbols. - IGBT or MOSFET, the choice this bears on.
- Switching at zero is the failure case, the second question.
- Soft switching puts
k²Qagainst the threshold and says which side of it a given coil is on.
The SSTC department diagram draws the primary beside the secondary on one axis, because being close is the only way they are coupled at all, and on an SSTC it has to be very close.